A line score with runs, hits and errors and lineups with positions. One letter page, free PDF, no sign-up.
Write both lineups with positions before the game. After each half inning, write runs in the line score, and add up runs, hits and errors at the end.
Rec leagues often use an extra hitter (EH) so more players bat; list them in the order with EH as the position.
Runs, hits and errors: the game's total runs, hits by that team, and errors made by that team in the field.
Usually 7 innings or a time limit, often around 60 minutes, with no new inning started once time is up.