A line score by inning and kicking orders for both teams. One letter page, free PDF, no sign-up.
Write both teams and their kicking orders. After each half inning, write that team's runs in the line score, then add them up in the Runs column at the end.
If your league plays to a time limit, mark the inning when time is called.
Most adult rec games are 7 innings or about 55 minutes, whichever comes first. The line score has room for 9 in case of extra innings.
Most coed leagues alternate men and women in the kicking order, and many require a set number of each in the field. Write your order before the game so it's easy to follow.